Is the Tax Code Fair? - Ep #108
It’s Tax Day — the one day of the year when millions of Americans collectively ask the same question: Did I pay too much…or too little?
But another question quickly follows: Is everyone else paying their fair share?
In this episode, we explore one of the most debated topics in economics and politics — the fairness of the U.S. tax system. We examine how income and wealth are taxed differently, look at what the latest IRS data actually shows about who pays federal income taxes, and discuss current policy debates such as proposed wealth taxes.
You may be surprised by what the numbers reveal.
In the Tips, Tricks, and Strategies segment, we also discuss how reviewing your recently filed tax return can help you make smarter tax planning decisions for the year ahead.
In This Episode, You’ll Learn:
About Tax Day and the Emotional Side of Taxes
Why Income and Wealth are Taxed Differently
The “Borrow, Spend, Die” Strategy
The Warren Buffett Example
What the IRS Data Actually Shows
The Wealth Tax Debate
Tax Day and the Emotional Side of Taxes
Taxes are more than numbers — they’re emotional. Every election cycle raises the question of whether Americans pay too much or whether certain groups pay too little.
Economist Thomas Sowell once joked:
“Elections should be held on April 16th — the day after we pay our income taxes.”
The quote highlights how differently people view taxation depending on when they’re writing the check.
Income vs. Wealth: Why They’re Taxed Differently
A key factor in the fairness debate is that income and wealth are taxed in very different ways.
Income
Wages and salary
Business income
Taxed progressively (higher income = higher rates)
Wealth
Stocks
Real estate
Business ownership
Usually taxed only when assets are sold
Because wealth is often unrealized, individuals can sometimes access it through borrowing strategies without triggering taxes.
The “Borrow, Spend, Die” Strategy
Some wealthy individuals use what’s often called the borrow, spend, die strategy:
Borrow against investments rather than selling them
Spend the borrowed funds
Pass assets to heirs when they pass away
Because assets may receive a step-up in basis at death, the capital gains taxes can be significantly reduced.
This strategy is one reason critics argue the tax code favors asset owners over wage earners.
The Warren Buffett Example
Investor Warren Buffett famously said that he pays a lower tax rate than his secretary.
While statements like this often fuel public debate, they also highlight an important distinction between:
Tax rates
Total taxes paid
Even when rates differ, the wealthiest taxpayers still pay very large total amounts of tax.
What the IRS Data Actually Shows
The most recent IRS data (2022) reveals that the federal income tax system is already highly progressive.
Top 1%
Income: ~$663,000+ AGI
Average tax rate: 26.1%
Share of federal income taxes paid: 40.4%
Bottom 50%
Income: ~$50,000 or less
Average tax rate: 3.7%
Share of federal income taxes paid: 3%
Key takeaway:
The top 1% earns roughly 22% of income but pays more than 40% of federal income taxes.
The Wealth Tax Debate
Recent policy proposals — including some state initiatives — have revived discussion about wealth taxes.
Supporters argue they would address wealth inequality by taxing large accumulations of assets.
Critics argue wealth taxes would require governments to:
Value assets every year
Assess taxes on unrealized wealth
Expand government oversight into private property
Regardless of where someone stands politically, the debate reflects a larger issue:
The U.S. tax system is complicated, and fairness is difficult to define.
Tips, Tricks, and Strategies
Conduct a “Tax Post-Mortem”
Now that you’ve filed your taxes, take a few minutes to review your return and ask a few key questions.
1. Did You Withhold Too Much?
A large refund might feel good — but it means you gave the government an interest-free loan during the year.
If your refund was larger than $1,000–$2,000, consider adjusting your withholding.
2. Review Your Marginal vs. Effective Tax Rate
Remember:
Marginal tax rate = rate applied to your last dollar of income
Effective tax rate = your overall average tax rate
Understanding the difference can help guide decisions like:
Retirement contributions
Roth conversions
Income timing strategies
3. Look at Your Adjusted Gross Income (AGI)
Review your AGI and see:
Which tax bracket you fell into
How close you were to the next bracket
If you were near a threshold, planning opportunities may exist for future years.
Key Takeaway
The fairness of the tax code will always be debated.
But instead of trying to solve the national tax system, the most productive step you can take is to focus on your own tax strategy.
Better planning leads to better outcomes.
And good financial planning always includes tax planning.
References
SOI Tax Stats - Individual statistical tables by tax rate and income percentile | Internal Revenue Service
If You Enjoyed This Episode
Be sure to:
Follow the podcast
Share the episode with someone preparing their taxes
Leave a review to help others discover the show
Ready to plan your ideal retirement? Schedule a free consultation with our team.
Connect with Jonny on LinkedIn
This information is not intended to be a substitute for specific individualized tax or legal advice. We suggest that you discuss your specific situation with a qualified tax or legal advisor.
Subscribe to ONE FOR THE MONEY on
Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Google Podcasts
Audio Production by
